Monday, April 30, 2012

Norman makes visible, via the problem of design, the paradox of technology (p. 31): “The same technology that simplifies life by providing more functions in each device also complicates life by making the device harder to learn, harder to use.”

Can you provide an example from your own life experiences that elucidates this idea?
Star & Bowker's work argues that classification can be used as a tool of…
1. Social order
2. Cultural exclusion/oppression
3. Marginalization of diversity
Can you provide examples from Chapter 6 of their book that elucidate these relationships?

Norman offers clues to how artifacts/objects/interfaces work:

Affordance: (p. 9) “…affordance refers to the perceived and actual properties of the thing, primarily those fundamental properties that determine just how the thing could possibly be used.” Norman uses the examples of chairs affording support/sitting, glass affording seeing through/smashing, and wood affording carving/writing.

Constraints: (p. 12) the condition of an object that indicates “that the number of possible actions is limited.” Using the example of a pair of scissors: “The holes are affordances: they allow the fingers to be inserted. The sizes of the holes provide constraints to limit the possible fingers: the big hole suggests several fingers, the small hole only one.”

Mapping: (p. 12) “…the set of possible operations.” (p. 23) “Mapping is a technical term meaning the relationship between two things…” Norman argues for the importance of natural mapping in design (p. 23) “Natural mapping, by which I mean taking advantage of physical analogies and cultural standards, leads to immediate understanding.”

Feedback: (p. 27) “Feedback – sending back to the user information about what action has actually been done, what result has been accomplished…”

Why is feedback so important for users?
How are Norman's understandings of conceptual models different from mental models?


Kuhlthau identifies 5 zones of intervention.

Z1: The problem is self-diagnosed, the need for information self-determined, and a search self-conducted. Type of mediation/education: requires an organized collection but no formal intervention design.

Z2: The problem requires a particular information source.

Type of mediation/education: Ready reference and single source or single session interventions address this zone.

Z3: The problem requires relevant sources. Type of mediation/education: Reference interventions or a series or these interactions in which a group of sources are introduced.

Z4: The problem requires a sequence for using relevant sources. Type of mediation/education: An instructional session for using sources in a recommended sequence.

Z5: The problem is ongoing, changing, and evolving. Type of mediation/education: A counselor engages in process interventions which provide guidance in identifying and interpreting information to address and evolving problem (p. 131).

Which zone represents traditional bibliographic instruction?  Which zone is similar to information literacy instruction?

Sunday, April 29, 2012

What are pre-coordinate (controlled) vocabularies?
What are post-coordinate (controlled) vocabularies?


Can you provide an example of each?
What is subject access?  How does it differ from other forms of searching?


Do Flickr, Del.icio.us, and LibraryThing leverage folksonomies?  If yes, in what way?
Can you describe 3 types of web-based metadata?

1. Professionally created: Catalog records – detailed rulesets and vocabularies (e.g. MARC).

2. Author created: Mostly on the WWW – SGML (XML), Dublin Core.



3. User created: Citation analysis, page-rank algorithm, recommendation systems, weblog, Folksonomies.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
What is Web 2.0?  The use of interactive, social technologies in web contexts.  Can you provide some examples of Web 2.0 technologies?
What do we mean by Library 2.0?
What are metadata?


Metadata: Data about data; developed by people for a purpose; object does not determine metadata, needs/purposes do; a slice of the world in a particular moment; a surrogate for the real thing; can be reused rather than reinvented.


What is the difference between professionalized metadata (such as library cataloging) and community-based metadata?


Please be able to define the following factors of information seeking:

1. Factors of information seeking: Information seeking depends on interactions among several factors: information seeker, task, search system, domain, setting, and search outcomes.


2. Information seeker: defines the task, controls interaction with the search system, examines, and extracts relevant information, assesses progress, and determines when the information seeking process is complete.


3. Professional Intermediaries: individuals who regularly conduct searchers for others – demonstrate expertise in information seeking through their knowledge of different search systems and strategies for assisting people in articulating tasks.


4. Task: the manifestation of an information seeker’s problem and is what drives information seeking actions.

5. Search system: a source that represents knowledge and provides tools and rules for accessing and using that knowledge. Database and interface realities both afford and constrain information seeking behavior

6. Database: the knowledge potentially available to an information seeker.


7. Interface: the representations of that knowledge and the tools, rules, and mechanisms for accessing and manipulating it.

8. Domain: a body of knowledge (e.g., history or chemistry) composed of entities and relationships.
9. Setting: The context for information seeking – has physical and conceptual/social components, including whether the task is done in collaboration or alone and the information seeker’s physical and psychological states.
10. Search Outcomes: products and process that impart information.
There are several "key" human-centered models of information seeking.  
Who has developed the following?
1. Sense-making and situation-gap-use models of information seeking.
2. Anomalous states of knowledge (ASK) framework.
3.  Kuhlthau: Zones of Intervention model; takes in to consideration affective and cognitive perspectives.
The emotional state of the user drives the trajectory of searching and interaction with IR system.  Can you describe some examples of the role of affect in Information Seeking? 


Information Seeking in Context (ISIC) is a research approach to studying user practice and behavior as contextualized within activity, task, or professionalized participation. How does this approach to research represent the LIS movement of focus from systems to users?